Why Eminem Isn’t Elvis

September 6th, 2011 by Dan Charnas
Filed in: , , , , ,

(Written for HuffingtonPost Black Voices)

In July, RollingStone.com commissioned Village Voice pop music columnist Chris Molanphy to craft a feature called “Introducing the King of Hip-Hop.”

The request came after the success of Molanphy’s previous post for the website, “Introducing the Queen of Pop” — in which Molanphy measured female music artists’ commercial performance in nine different ways and tallied the results. “Queen of Pop” crowned Lady Gaga, garnered 2000 Facebook “Likes” and engendered hundreds of comments-worth of bile from livid fans of Madonna and Brittany Spears.

For “King of Hip-Hop,” Molanphy consolidated his nine parameters into just seven — album sales, album reviews, chart position, touring, social media, YouTube hits, and awards — and tweaked his spreadsheet a bit, weighing album sales, chart position, and YouTube heavier, and giving less weight to social networking and reviews. Fatefully, Molanphy reprised the “Queen of Pop” survey’s irregular time period, a two-and-a-half year span between the beginning of 2009 and mid-2011, so that the data sample would be big enough. All Molanphy had to do was collect the data and crunch the numbers.

Not long after he started entering the figures, Molanphy stopped by Woodwork, a bar near his home in Brooklyn, to meet up with some friends. They asked him how his project was going.

“It’s clear Eminem’s going to win this thing,” Molanphy told them.

Oh man, his friends said. You are gonna get hounded for the white guy taking the crown.

A Higher Caliber of Haterade

On August 15, 2011, after Eminem was crowned the “King of Hip-Hop” by the website of the 44-year old rock-and-roll magazine Rolling Stone, the reaction from many hip-hop fans, culture critics and other social commentators was baffled and dismissive.

“This list is bogus on every criterion and smolders with racism,” commented one RollingStone.com reader, Chino Wilson. “Somehow out of all the hip hop artists, you Rolling Stone anoint a white one, Eminem as the King of Hip Hop? Eminem himself would tell you he’s not worthy of that throne.”

Jasmine ‘Jazzi’ Johnson on TheGrio.com said of Eminem: “Though he’s always been a great artist with a dynamic delivery, the masses of White America tend to run out and support any and everything he does regardless of its quality,”

The results reviled like those of his “Queen of Pop” post, Molanphy’s hip-hop piece was similarly successful by Web standards, where outrage creates revenue — with over 5000 Facebook likes and nearly 200 comments.

What many readers didn’t realize was that the results of the research were skewed by a two major factors. The first was the peculiar time period of the survey, which happened to coincide with a prolific comeback for Eminem after a five-year hiatus in which he released two albums. “Eminem got lucky with our timing,” Molanphy says. “Before then, he doesn’t even factor.”

The second was the blockbuster pop success of Eminem’s duet with Rihanna, “Love The Way You Lie,” which boosted Eminem’s album sales, awards, chart positions and YouTube plays significantly.  Without the song, Molanphy says, “it increases the likelihood that Lil Wayne takes it.”

Those realities — added to the heavy-weighting of album sales and Eminem’s peculiar strength as an album artist — took Eminem over the top. “If there was one pleasant surprise, it was that the numbers in the top three were closer then I thought they would be,” Molanphy says. “This at least feels you’ve got two other guys who could have given Eminem a run for his money. The whole top five feels legit to me. I may not like the order,” — Molanphy says he is partial to Kanye on a creative level — “but I like that it’s Jay, Kanye, Wayne, Drake, and Eminem.”

If Numbers Don’t Lie, Why Doesn’t It Ring True?

Eminem’s perch at the pinnacle of this particular poll might not have aroused such ire if the piece had not used one particular word in its title:

“King.”

As most students of pop culture know, the use of the term “King” has an antecedent in music history. Hip-hop’s predecessor, rhythm-and-blues, was the last musical genre to grow from Black communities to dominate the mainstream. But rhythm & blues renamed didn’t make it into the mainstream unadulterated. The music was renamed “rock and roll,” and its Black originators were largely denied access to promotion, airplay and venues. So rock-and-roll’s first stars were white. And translator number one was Elvis Presley. A segregated entertainment industry and a willfully ignorant media could, then, easily crown Elvis “The King of Rock-and-Roll.”

It was a usurpation of the throne. The mention of Elvis as a “King” of anything still rankles some who regard the Mississippi-born R&B artist as either a cultural thief, or at least a culpable accessory to the crime, like so many other beneficiaries of a white supremacist system.

Thus the word “Elvis” itself became epithet, hurled at any white artist who achieved success performing Black-originated American music at the perceived expense of Black originators.

And no one, perhaps, in pop culture since Elvis has triggered this comparison to Elvis more than Eminem.

But is Eminem really Elvis redux?

A History Lesson

A few weeks before the “King Of Hip-Hop” piece came out, I appeared on a panel at the Harlem Book Fair to discuss the dramatic ascent of Black American artists and entrepreneurs in the hip-hop era chronicled in my book, The Big Payback: The History of the Business of Hip-Hop.

An audience member asked me, regarding the success of Eminem: “Do you really think we’ve passed that Elvis mentality where we have to have white artists co-opt black culture?”

I answered, “Yes and no,” because the issue can’t really be understood without about 400 years of context.

Black culture has always been fascinating to white Americans, even as white America subjugated Black people.  Long before the American descendants of Europeans were willing to acknowledge the humanity of the descendants of Africans, white Americans recognized it subconsciously, by proxy: reveling in music, dance and language loaded with African retentions that, in fitting irony, would become the foundation of all American pop culture.

The entire music industry, founded in the Jim Crow era of segregation, was built on two fallacies: that there was, indeed, some existential difference between so-called “Black” music and white “pop” music other than the race of the musicians; and that white America needed white translators to interpret and “tone down” Black art for them.

Both premises were disproved by the 1960s, as AM radio blasted Black artists to white America, and artists like James Brown and Aretha Franklin shared space on pop playlists with the Beatles and the Rolling Stones.

But this “golden age” of relative cultural parity died with the Sixties, as corporations bought up independent record companies to claim a piece of the lucrative “Black music” market, subsuming them under “Black” departments; and organized radio stations with rigid race-based programming “formats”: Led Zeppelin and Rush over here; Stevie Wonder and Earth, Wind & Fire over there.

The music business resegregated under the concept of “crossover” — meaning that Black artists had to “prove” their commercial viability in the “Black” market before being considered for pop promotion. And even with proven success, viable Black artists could still be turned away for sounding “too Black.” It took the full political weight of CBS Records executives to induce MTV to play Michael Jackson’s “Billie Jean” video in 1983.  Michael Jackson, and Prince shortly thereafter, loosened things up for Black artists on the nascent cable channel that had become America’s prime outlet for promoting music. But only just a bit. The music industry was still as segregated as ever.

In the end, it wouldn’t be musicians who knocked down those walls.

Rhymin’ & Stealin’

In 1984, Run-DMC were the first rap group in history to get played on MTV. As a result, they became hip-hop’s first mainstream stars.

So when the group’s producers, Russell Simmons and Rick Rubin, chose to follow Run-DMC’s success with a hip-hop album from a white, former punk band called the Beastie Boys, it seemed an historic inevitability—as Black music styles throughout history had each been adopted, in succession, by white musicians. Simmons and Rubin may have even been familiar with the old adage attributed to the man who discovered Elvis: “If I could find a white man who had the Negro sound and the Negro feel, I could make a billion dollars.”

But Russell Simmons was not Sam Phillips. Simmons, the manager, was Black. If the white group became successful, a Black man would profit first.

The Beastie Boys were nevertheless greeted by some cultural critics as the Elvises of hip-hop. Here we go again, they seemed to say. Just like rock-and-roll. In a few years, no one will even know that hip-hop was a Black art form, and all of its major stars will be white.

The initial success of the Beastie Boys seemed to bear that out. Their white skin privilege laded their faces on mainstream music magazines that had never given similar coverage to Black rap artists. Their 1986 album, “Licensed To Ill,” sold four million albums, easily topping Run-DMC’s record of three million.

Yet though the Beasties’ sold millions of records and concert tickets, there came no deluge of white rap groups in their wake. You’ve forgotten their names, if you ever knew them—The White Boys, B.M.O.C.—they all failed. In fact, the next white crew of significant sales and reputation came three years later: 3rd Bass, whose frontman MC Serch took pains both to credit hip-hop’s originators and blend in with the current crop of hip-hop artists. Serch openly reviled the Beastie Boys and Rubin as hip-hop carpetbaggers, even while the Beasties were cheered by hip-hop purists for their experimental second album, Paul’s Boutique.

The Iceman Cometh

“Yo! MTV Raps” debuted in 1988, becoming the most popular show on the channel. “Yo!” pumped hardcore rap videos into American living rooms, but emphasized visual over lyrical artists.  Not long after “Yo!” broke MC Hammer’s “U Can’t Touch Dis,” the simplistic song was embraced by pop programmers — a Black rapper easily outselling the Beasties at 10 million albums. Hammer was followed, by a white doppelganger, Vanilla Ice.

Again, the doom-chorus comparisons to Elvis rang out. (I was, by the way, one of the voices in that chorus back then: “Just like that,” I wrote in The Source in 1990, “an entire generation of cultural genius is smothered in an avalanche of mediocrity.”)

“Ice Ice Baby” became the first rap single to go #1 on the pop charts, and Vanilla Ice sold 9 million albums.

But the appearance of Vanilla Ice as the Great White Hope was not followed by a great whitening of hip-hop. Anyone remember the female version of Vanilla Ice, Icy Blu? Didn’t think so. Vanilla Ice quickly flamed out and melted. Hammer, his Black counterpart and the originator of Ice’s pop style, ultimately sold more albums and had a much longer career.

Crossover Becomes Takeover

Hammer and Ice faded in part because older white pop radio programmers were being replaced by a younger generation that had more knowledge of hip-hop’s currency with mainstream audiences. So more hardcore artists like Dr. Dre, Cypress Hill, A Tribe Called Quest, The Notorious B.I.G. and Wu-Tang became pop radio staples, and the number one music stations in America’s top two markets, New York and L.A., embraced hip-hop as pop music.

What happened over the next decade was unprecedented. Black hip-hop artists became America’s pop stars; not just in the world of music, but on TV and in film. They educated themselves on the business and began to balk at deals that didn’t accord them significant ownership of their product. They leveraged the power of their brand names into fashion and consumer products companies that ultimately brought them more wealth than their recording careers did. Never before in American history had the Black creators of American culture retained the degree of control over their own direction and the ability to profit from it. In 1998, both Master P and Sean Combs hit near the top of the Forbes highest-paid entertainers list, followed closely by a former rapper named Will Smith.

My Name Is…

Dr. Dre had been a hip-hop kingmaker for years, spawning the careers of Eazy E, Ice Cube and Snoop Dogg, when he happened upon the demo tape of a white MC from Detroit named Marshall Mathers. The kid who called himself “Eminem” had already made a name for himself on the rap battle circuit, fighting his way to the penultimate spot in the national Rap Olympics and appearing on the nationally-syndicated Sway & Tech Wake-Up radio show. Before Dre ever got the idea to make Eminem his next protege, Eminem was an obscure but well-respected MC by people in hip-hop whose opinions mattered.

Whether Dre and his partner Jimmy Iovine at Interscope Records had that same Sam Phillips impulse isn’t clear. What is clear is that the success of Eminem’s million-selling debut in 1999 came from a confluence of several factors. Being a white MC cosigned by a famous artist or producer wasn’t sufficient. Being those things and really competent at what he did apparently was.

Here he is, the chorus sang again. The Elvis of hip-hop. This is how it starts. It’s all over now.

The cultural Cassandras who had cried Elvis twice before said that it was different this time. Some said that the Beastie Boys and Vanilla Ice weren’t scary good in the way that Eminem was scary good. The theory here was that once white kids found a white MC who could truly approximate Black skills, they’d flock to him and forget the rest.

Others insisted that Eminem wasn’t so special —  he only seemed so because of his white skin privilege and the promotion it afforded him. Plenty of Black MCs out there, they said, with better skills but none of the attention. The theory here was that industry gatekeepers, with their powers and access, would purposely elevate Eminem as a demigod to a white audience who obviously didn’t know any better.

Over the next few years, Eminem accumulated an astounding sales record, eclipsing almost every rap artist who preceded him, seemingly proving the Elvis theory right.

And yet, within six years, Eminem had all-but vanished from the scene, eclipsed in many ways by his own artist — 50 Cent — and by the extraordinary creative and financial successes of Black hip-hop stars-turned-moguls like Jay-Z, and Sean Combs. Nearly a decade after Eminem’s debut, hip-hop was still young America’s pop music, and the face of that music was still Black.

A Reality Check

Eminem is not actually the top-selling hip-hop artist of all time. Tupac is.

Eminem is not the top-earning hip-hop artist, either.  His net worth doesn’t approach that of either Jay, Diddy, Fiddy, Dre, or Bird, the greatest of them approaching a half-billion dollars.

Taking the long view, rather than the two-and-a-half year frame of RollingStone.com’s survey, Eminem becomes a lone white face in the pack, not an Aryan colossus atop a pile of crushed MCs. Exceptional, he is. But he is also the exception.

Which brings us back to the question that kicked off this whole history lesson: “Do you really think we’ve passed that Elvis mentality where we have to have white artists co-opt black culture?”

Here’s the answer:

The truth is that white kids never needed white artists to translate Black culture for them. It’s just that Black artists were prevented from competing for their ears—first by Jim Crow, then by the segregationists in corporate music and radio. You just can see the effects of four decades of music business racism in this list.

True, white artists often resonate with white fans. Eminem does appeal to a contingent of white kids who, for reasons of cultural identity, see themselves in him. But given the history we’ve laid out above, that racial resonance is clearly not paramount. The history of American pop music has, in fact, moved inexorably toward the subversion of racial boundaries—a process delayed only by industry gatekeepers who resisted the more advanced and adventurous tastes of the kids whom they purported to serve.

American radio was still kept highly segregated by those gatekeepers in 1979, the year that the first rap records were made. In December of that year, only two of the acts in the Billboard Top 10 singles chart were Black: the Commodores and Stevie Wonder.

Flash forward over two decades in hip-hop history. Those old gatekeepers had long been swept away. On October 6, 2003, for the first time in history, every single act in the Billboard Top 10 was Black.

But old perceptions die hard. That same year, Ebony Magazine published a photo of Eminem next to another of Elvis in an uncredited screed called “Why White Stars Are Ripping Off  Rap & R&B,” as if proximity and resemblance amounted to guilt. Meanwhile Eminem’s protege, 50 Cent, was preparing to purchase a stake in Vitamin Water that would ultimately make him much richer than his mentor.

Why Hip-Hop Is Different

The long legacy of white supremacy still informs the structure of society and industry. Black interests do not have much control of the overall entertainment business, even though they manufacture much of the intellectual and creative capital. But it is incontestable that Black artists and entrepreneurs control more of the their own business and direct more of the cultural conversation than ever before. That’s what makes hip-hop different from rock-and-roll, ultimately. It’s interesting that in all the hullaballoo about the “King of Hip-Hop” piece, one fact got lost: Rolling Stone’s “Queen of Pop,” Lady Gaga, is signed to a production entity owned by a Black man, Akon. And that’s why Akon, too, is worth more than Eminem.

In stark contrast to white rock and rollers like Elvis and The Crew Cuts—whose R&B remakes pushed the originators work off the charts—the rare white hip-hop act, whether the Beasties, Vanilla Ice, or Eminem, hardly denied MCs of color access to audiences or riches. Their anomalous successes did not set off a wave of successful white MCs, promoted by all-powerful corporate interests, embraced by the supposedly ambivalent white masses with their thirst for Black culture and fear of Black people, erasing the Black roots of hip-hop from memory. It just never happened. If it ever did, where then are the legions of white rappers overtaking us? Why does Eminem remain the only white dude near the top? Here’s why:

Hip-hop has remained in some ways what made it so uniquely powerful in the first place: An African-American art form that succeeds as pop music, all the while remaining tied irrevocably to the Black experience, and to the struggle of its participants—whether Black, white, Asian, or Latino—to live a multiracial life in a nation still not mature or wise enough to be truly multiracial.

That’s actually who Eminem is. If you’ve watched him over the course of his career, Eminem has never allowed himself to be marketed in the way that Elvis was — as an originator or a “King.” He has, in many ways, remained what he was in the beginning: a humble but excellent participant in the culture (despite being goaded by less talented detractors), deferent to his influences and his peers, but a ferocious competitor on the microphone.

Eminem isn’t Elvis. If anything, as my friend Davey D has analogized on his blog, he’s Larry Bird: “Like Bird, he respects the game and has paid his dues.  He’s good. He’s frustratingly good.” (Paying dues, being good and a bit of humility make all the difference. Not having any one of those things is a hip-hop career killer. Just ask Asher Roth. The question of quality, credibility and attitude is a gauntlet that white female rapper Kreayshawn is running right now.)

Pause For The Cause

“It wasn’t so much that we disliked Larry Bird,” Davey D continued. “It had more to do with the announcers and sports pundits who… would go on and on and on about how great Larry Bird was as if Julius Irving, Magic Johnson and everyone else did not exist.”

It is mainstream media’s history of focusing on hip-hop’s white stars that have folks very cynical about the “King of Hip-Hop” survey.

“For me Rolling Stone’s crowning of Eminem as ‘king’ is akin to the government of one nation telling another who their president is,” commented Juba Zaki on the site. “There’s nothing wrong in using statistics to state facts… However, the title of this article should properly reflect the magazines relationship to Hip Hop, which is far from authoritative.”

Did they consider changing the title? Chris Molanphy recalls: “Having already done ‘Queen of Pop,’ I felt we were kind of locked into… ‘King of Hip-Hop,’”

“When I first crunched the data, I showed them to my editors,” Molanphy recalls. “I said, ‘It’s gut check time. This is who’s gonna win. Tell me if this makes you uncomfortable.’ I was hoping they weren’t going to say, ‘Oh yeah, come up with a chicanerous way to make Lil Wayne win.’ But nobody said that. They didn’t have a whole lot of pause, I didn’t have a whole lot of pause.”

It’s unfortunate that the survey wasn’t expanded or reframed, because Rolling Stone over the last decade has significantly improved its hip-hop coverage, and they’ve hired a number of folks who do care deeply about the genre. It’s a shame to jeopardize that good work in the name of neutrality and objectivity, especially when that neutrality and objectivity gives people the impression that you have no neutrality and objectivity.

Cross-racial connections and partnerships, like the kind I chronicle in The Big Payback, are delicate. In this climate, they are like a patch of seedlings ever in danger of being trampled. The real repercussion of this episode is that it gives fuel to folks who insist that our dark history will always repeat itself, a reaction to other folks who seem to be saying that history can be so easily discounted. One group is looking at history with their left eye closed, and the other is looking with their right eye shut. We need both eyes open now for some depth perception.

We face bigger problems than some Internet debate. We can’t afford to exaggerate change. Neither can we afford to discount or trivialize it. This is a time of transition for America, a slow, painful and dangerous shift — not to a “post-racial” society, but to a multiracial, multicultural one. The election of Obama is only the beginning of this period. We will see a violent back and forth as the reactionary forces flame dangerously and then sputter out.

A few months before the release of the list, a white teenager in Mississippi named Daryl Dedmon was arrested for the killing of a Black working man named James Craig Anderson. To look at Anderson’s alleged killer, one might reasonably conclude that nothing fundamental has changed in that state since days of Elvis Aaron Presley’s childhood there, nor in this country. What does it take, after all, to transform a nation forged in the monstrous institution of slavery and turn it into something human and equitable?

It takes more time. For every kid like Dedmon whom the cultural revolution fails to touch—not to say that it even could have—there are many more whom it does. The fight is often fought house to house, hand to hand, heart to heart.

Elvis was an early, imperfect product of this match—a kid who was fascinated by Black culture but had neither the facilities to realize nor the power to blunt his role as an appropriator.

Eminem, the kid from Detroit, however, is a late model, a different breed. If you look at him with both eyes open, you’ll see that Marshall Mathers is not the problem. He is, in fact, part of the solution.

Dan Charnas is the author of The Big Payback: The History of the Business of Hip-Hop, and an Editorial Director at InteractiveOne.

49 Responses to “Why Eminem Isn’t Elvis”

  1. King Of Authors says:

    Dan is a moron it seems like he wants Elvis to be crowned the King Of Hip Hop, I woder if Dan ever heard Eminems music other than Radio hit singles.
    Eminem has sold more than any other hip hop artist. Also he is the top selling artist of the 2000′s. Recovery came out 2 years after The Carter 3 and still outsold it by 2 million. Check the facts before you post something like this idiot.

    • MXL says:

      This post is head-shakingly ignorant. It’s hard to tell if your failure was in the reading of Dan’s piece or in the comprehension of it, but I’m thinking it’s a bit of both. It’s proof that, for some, Eminem stannery trumps all logical analysis.

      • 911 says:

        All logical analysis? Give me a break . Your logical analysis are a matter of opinion and speculation. Eminems “crowning” is based of FACTS.
        Numbers dont lie homegirl.
        I grew up on the south side of Chicago and everyone at school was listening to The Eminem show back when I was in High School, now Im in Afghanistan and soldiers are bumping their heads to Bad Meets Evil and Recovery. The cafeteria plays his shit. Details like that count, thats how he is nearing 100 million albums sold.
        He is a worldwide star, they know him in places where Wayne could walk and no one would know him. I been all over the world and he is everywhere, offcouse Dan and people like MXL who sit behind their keyboard in their mothers basement ARGUING facts wouldnt know shit and they dont.
        Dude dont gotta talk about 24-inch rims, grills or money to sell records, thats played out shit.

        Eminem , King of Hip Hop forever. Fuck “analysis” just open your eyes and look around.

        • Anon says:

          You’re old enough to be a soldier, yet you have the comprehension ability of a child. Scary. Hope they only let you handle the water canteens in Afghanistan.

          Just so you know though, everything you said in your post has nearly nothing to do with this article. You’re basically arguing with nobody.

        • Callog says:

          Yeah, it is obvious you are a soldier for a reason. I’m sure there isn’t much you can do besides that from the sound of it. I’m from Detroit, and I was great friends with Proof (Eminems best friend)and everyone here in Detroit’s hip-hop scene respect Em for sure. I think hip-hop as a whole respect Em. However, to crown him the King Of Hip-Hop is not the Rolling Stones place or your’s, for that matter.

          In addition, you telling us Eminem is a worldwide star in a white man’s world further shows me why we need you to stay in Afghanistan. How do you think he got there genius? No disrespect to Em and his accomplishment, but it’s like he said. ” I know the math if I was black I would have only sold half” -Mashall Mathers

        • Real hip hop says:

          Asshole that u r. Numbers do lie. Mc hammer sold more than rakim, kool g rap and krs 1 but was he better ? Hell fuckin no. and if u talk numbers then pac is the king hands down. If u want to talk money then u have to give it to fifty, jay or diddy. Em is very good but no where near the best or king of hip hop.

  2. Jaime Burrows says:

    If B.B. King has no problem in Presley having been called the King of Rock and Roll (by Variety magazine, in November of 1956, in spite of their little knowing that the title, along with the rock and roll craze, would go on to last for the next 60 years), then the matter of Eminem never allowing himself to be marketed in the way that Elvis was — as an originator or a “King.” If you don’t belive me, go to youtube, do the research, then find what Presley told an audience of 17,000 attending a concert at Notre Dame when he saw a huge banner being held by about 20 girsl, saying he was the King. I’ll make it easier for you. He stopped the concert, and asked them to remove it, for according to him, there was only one King, and that was Jesus Christ. They hesitated, then he raised his voice and said. If you want me to contunue, get rid of it. And they did.

  3. Jaime Burrows says:

    This is how the message should read.

    If B.B. King has no problem with Presley having been called the “King of Rock and Roll” (by Variety magazine, in November of 1956, in spite of their little knowing that the title, along with the rock and roll craze, would go on to last for the next 60 years), then the matter of “Eminem never allowing himself to be marketed in the way that Elvis was — as an originator or a “King.” is dead on arrival. If you don’t believe me, go to youtube, do the research, then find what Presley told an audience of 17,000 attending a concert at the University of Notre Dame when he saw a huge banner being held by about 20 girls, saying he was the King. I’ll make it easier for you. He stopped the concert, and asked them to remove it for, according to him, there was only one King, and that was Jesus Christ. They hesitated, then he raised his voice and said. “If you want me to contunue, get rid of it”. And they did.

  4. Jaime Burrows says:

    There are over 200 radio interviews, all available in the net and emanating from the two year period from 1955 to 1957, when Presley decidedly informs (LOL) whoever is interviewing him, that rock and roll is pretty old, and that it used to be called R&B. Then, as if to settle the matter once and for all, he told an estimated TV audience of 50 million (December 3, 1968), essentially the same thing. If there weren’t too many African Americans watching that night, it is certainly not Presley’s fault. Presley neither thought himself as an originator, nor the King of anything. And that’s why Presley is Elvis, and not the other way around.

  5. White people are angry because they CAN’T co-op hip-hop the way they did rock thus Eminem “King of Hip-Hop.” There is no “King Of Hip-Hop” there’s a king of commercial hip-hop sales and as you have written Em doesn’t even have that. This is about a cultural war that has whites baffled as to how something that was supposed to be a fad 30 years ago is still around and culturally controlled by Blacks. Eminem and any other white rapper can mimic Black music all day but they can NEVER determine its course. Rolling Stone wouldn’t even exist if Black people hadn’t invented rock music. At least Eminem put a lot of Black people on which is more than I can say about The Beasties and their Free Tibet campaign. This whole thing is a sad joke.

  6. Cdes says:

    With regards to the sales figures – stop pretending that Hip-Hop/Rap is solely an American phenomenon. Tupac may very well outsell Eminem domestically – but Eminem strides past him internationally – where it matters.

    Doesn’t success across cultural and linguistic boundaries say something very substantial about the pull of an artist?

    Just as Eminem gets perhaps more attention for being white, so too is he more reviled by conservative ‘purists’ for the same reason.

  7. Tom says:

    I am impressed with the amount of effort put into this article. I am however very taken back by the context of the article. I cannot imagine someone doing a similar article about Tiger Woods. I think a better question is why doesnt eminem get the respect in black community he deserves? Because despite what the “streets” think is tight other rappers beg to have eminem on a track. Eminem had way more to over come than Tiger Woods did to break into a predominantly white sport. Immediately he loses creditibility for being white. The only way eminem gains any credibility is by being insanly good. And lets be real if we can for once because this article wasnt. If eminem wasnt that much better than the competion he doesnt get signed by a major lable. Also if being white is the golden ticket in the “rap” game then how come no other white rapper since eminem has even come near his success. Lets face it eminem is a top 5 rapper ever. When people talk about rap in 20 years you know he well be brought up. The article rolling stone ran had no undertones of racisim. So why is Dan Charnas trying to incite this type of discussion? And by the way eminem is by far the highest selling rapper of all time. But that isnt what makes him so great. Its his skill and word play. People listen to him because he doesnt rap about being tight or rich beyond his wildest dreams. He has a very initimate relationship with his fans. And thats why people love and connect with his music. If I were the editor I would have demanded the article be revised.

    • MXL says:

      Tom, with all due respect, what makes you think that Eminem is not highly respected in the Black community? For the most part, we Black Hip-Hoppers absolutely love and respect the guy. I don’t think you fully understand how it works.

      Em didn’t immediately lose credibility because he’s White; his Whiteness just made it much more important that his skills were on point — and that’s because the precedent of skill-less, gimmicky White rap acts had already been set long before Em even landed on our radar. We of the Hip-Hop culture respect authenticity and TALENT, regardless of skin color. (Of course there are some who diss him and discount his skills because he’s White, but there are also Whites who deride him for even participating in such a decidedly colored culture.) There are plenty Black acts that those in the know don’t respect because they’re just flat-out wack (you know, the Soulja Boys and Lil’ B’s of the world). We may respect their hustle but never will you hear anyone with an opinion worth listening to refer to these acts as “dope MCs.” Eminem, on the other hand, is consistently counted among the elite.

      And where in this piece does Dan say that being White is the “golden ticket” in the rap game? It actually says the opposite.

      • Tom says:

        @MXL: I know eminem is respected in African American community. I was being very pithy and maybe my cynicism wasn’t coming through. My main point is if a similar article was written about Tiger what kind of response would Dan get? Rolling Stone isn’t an authority on hip hop. Eminem isn’t King of rap and wouldn’t claim to be. According to the narrow criteria Rolling stone used he has been crowned as such. But what I am asking is why is this so controversial? We both know if the award were given to wayne no such article would have been written. Eminem is clearly one of the few who are deserving of the title. So the point isn’t about whether or not eminem is deserving. It’s about why he isn’t deserving.

  8. Smh says:

    Eminem IS the best-selling hip-hop artist in the world. Eminem is easily ahead of Tupac in worldwide sales with 90 million+ as compared to 2Pac’s 76-78 million. In the U.S., RIAA shows that Eminem has sold 35 million, but the 40m mark has been breached after REC✚VƎRY was released. Tupac has sold around 37.5-38 million albums in the U.S. … And one more thing.. you’re an idiot – you just can’t fathom reality..

  9. Voice-Over says:

    Thank you regarding this kind of post, you make a good point and additionally I liked looking at it. Hope to discover more in the future. Cheers!

  10. urnumbersix says:

    Very good article!

    As an African-American woman, born, bred and living in Detroit — let me inform y’all — Eminem is the Real Deal!

    Always has been.

    He has Earned the respect of black folks around here.

    The author nailed it. He works “within” the genre. He’s not trying to “steal” it.

    Anyone looking at him sideways in the early days soon found plenty of his competitors willing to vouch for him. He always has worked hard and is extremely skilled.

    When young, he had anger-management-issues. Who didn’t? Through it all, he’s never played the supremacist or obsequent white. Though it might Seem like it to some – he ever played Wigger, either.

    About the only thing I can say he got “because he’s white” is the movie, “8 Mile.” And then, with No professional acting experience — he tore That up. So he Earned that Too!

    He has stayed in this area. Never went “L.A.” or “NYC.” Kept his crew. He has mentored, as he was mentored. He has matured.

    He still has Crazy-Mad-Skills….

  11. [...] Black, white, Asian, or Latinoto live a multiracial life in a nation still not mature or wise Full news story This entry was posted in Top Adult News and tagged asian hot mature, black man and mature white [...]

  12. [...] Why Eminem Is Not Elvis (GO) [...]

  13. Anon says:

    The Eminem/Elvis comparison has NEVER been accurate. Elvis didn’t write his own music, and he was not even remotely comparable talent-wise to Chuck Berry and Little Richard. I mean, not even remotely. That’s why Elvis firmly remains a part of 1950s nostalgia, while the popularity and lasting influence of The Beatles have far exceeded the 1960s. If it was considered socially acceptable for white people to favor black pop musicians over white ones, Elvis wouldn’t have had a career.

    Eminem, on the other hand, is (when he wants to be, meaning not when he’s targeting the pop-rap audience) one of the smartest, funniest, and most skilled rappers in hip-hop. And while it’s easy to think that Em’s skills have significantly decreased since his comeback, due to his biggest hits featuring not-so-impressive lyricism (including some really awful groan-worthy metaphors), a few of the deeper cuts on his recent albums (Underground, On Fire, Reunion) show otherwise. In fact, he’s even wittier and more self-aware than before.

    That said, this whole King of Hip-Hop thing is stupid, and was an obvious desperate attempt from RS magazine for attention. Rolling Stone hasn’t been relevant to music in decades. Glorified tabloid magazine. Obviously a 30 year-old genre isn’t going to have a king. The genre would’ve died out if there weren’t a ton of great artists.

    • eboyd says:

      Thank you! This is, by far, the most relevant and insightful comment here. It is, in fact, more relevant and insightful than the actual article. I was thinking exactly this and this comment expressed the words exactly how I was thinking them. Eminem has proven time and again that he is one of the most talented artists in hip hop. he nearly beat MC Juice — known by many as the greatest freestyle and battle emcee who has ever lived — in a freestyle battle, of all places at Scribble Jam, the Mecca of battle rap. He then went on to release two of the most commercially successful gimmick free, raw hip hop albums of all time (Slim Shady LP and Marshall Mathers LP), became a hip hop mogul and successful businessman in his own right, and went on to revive his own career nearly ten years after his initial reign of dominance. That said, his music recently has been, unfortunately gimmicky in large part. Though we do get glimpses of the old Eminem here and there, it’s not enough. What he needs is competition and really, there is no one providing that atm.

    • Callog says:

      Well said Anon.

  14. Stephen says:

    good article, although i’m not sure why there’s a need to capitalize Black every instance and leave white lowercase, just gives off a quasi-passive aggressive and biased fibe

  15. tim says:

    A fascinating article. I am white and have lived in inner city Detroit since 1970, and i can confirm that Eminem is highly respected here among blacks, and also among young whites. The Larry Bird comparison is apt; they are both seen not as robbers of black culture but as respecters of it who paid their dues in their fields ad earned their own respect due to “the content of their character,” to quote Dr. King.

    I would like to raise a different point. I grew up in an entirely white, working class area east of Cleveland in the 1950s, so i experienced the emergence of rock n roll first hand as it was received and perceived by young white working-class kids at the time. Maybe my experience was different from elsewhere in the country because the Cleveland DJ Alan Freed played all the artists (black and white rockers and also country) on the same station, but I will tell you that while we liked Elvis and Buddy Holly and the Everly Brothers, still Chuck Berry, Little Richard, Fats Domino, the Platters, the Penguins, the Coasters, Frankie Lyman, Ray Charles and other black performers were truly beloved. To jitterbug at lunch hour in the gym, Chuck Berry was the first answer, to slow dance with your girl at a Teen-Town on Friday night it was the Platters or the Penguins or Tab Hunter or Nat King Cole. There were a number of black girl-groups — the Shirelles? my memory fails — that we loved too. Elvis was just one of the stars that we liked, we didn’t call him “king.” But frankly, for the most rockin music or the most romantic it was the black groups. I can still sing more Platters songs than I can Elvis.

    I’m just saying that this: (your quote) “Both premises were disproved by the 1960s, as AM radio blasted Black artists to white America, and artists like James Brown and Aretha Franklin shared space on pop playlists with the Beatles and the Rolling Stones.” happened for us in Cleveland long before this.

    And you are quite right, the resegregation of music since then is tragic.

    I have another theory: that the black musicians of that time taught young whites, especially in the working class, to love. To me the white music of the previous generation, Frank Sinatra and such, was utterly bland and boring. Then came rock/r%b and in my life it was the black artists most of all, the Platters, Ray Charles, the Penguins, who released my romantic and sensual emotions in a much fuller and healthier way. Really, I think this is why the white kids like me went for it. It caught our hearts and our bodies at the same time. We were better people for it, people who were later capable, in surprising numbers, of stepping up to help black folks in the civil rights movement, to battle against the racist Vietnam war,etc., that is, to dare to change the world. These artists prepared us for Motown and Aretha and even Tupac and Eminem. They are and were both black and universal.

  16. Callog says:

    The Hip Hop community are the only people who can crown a king Hip Hop. Not wanna be a part of Hip Hop (obviously) Rolling Stone Magazine. Last I checked. We did not crown Eminem king. He is a great mc for sure, but he is not the king of Hip Hop. When we crown the king of Hip Hop, Rolling Stone magazine, you’ll know it. Until then stay in your lane and play your roll. You are not a Hip Hop authority, and it’s comical and nonsensical for you to try and come off as one. And for the white people talking all that smack if it wasn’t for black people. What would American music really be? Now, I know what you are going to say. Therefore, go ahead and get your racial insult out, but when you’re done. Answer the question! Even if it’s just to yourself! LMAO!

  17. Callog says:

    “I know the math if I was Black, I would have only sold half” -Marshall Mathers(Eminem)

  18. Highly challenging appreciate it, I believe your trusty followers would possibly want a good deal more reviews like that keep up the great work.

  19. Charles says:

    I don’t think we can say whether Eminem is Elvis or not while we’re still in the process of seeing what he’ll eventually become. The guy’s like 38, where will he be in the American psyche compared to his contemporaries in 20. I’m inclined to agree that he’s more comparable to larry bird than Elvis, but we don’t know yet. One thing I do disagree on, is the notion that white audiences never needed their music whitened. While there we always people who simply cared about good music, there was also always huge contingent of people that allowed their abillity to relate to the music be clouded by race, or culture or preconceived notions of black people or whatever. Those old radio guys didn’t come out of nowhere, they came from and knew places like those. That contingent is considerably smaller now and it was always more prevelant in some places than others, but it certainly existed in a much stronger way than this write acknowledges.

  20. I am full of admiration and positive impressions. Very nice, clean and pleasant. All the best for the author.

  21. Make $369+ a day on the side, part-time with my new system by the end of today. No bs, no tricks, I don’t have time for that kind of stuff. My friend told me you are searching for some extra income, well here I am. This is not an easy get rich quick scheme and you will have to do some work, but I’ll truly demonstrate step by step how to churn out cash grabbing websites in your very first day: http://earn-1100-weekly.info

  22. I think you have remarked some very interesting details , regards for the post.

  23. I will make use of this moment to share usually really enjoy your blog. It has been a very good resource of info to do. Thanks for your time!

  24. buty damskie says:

    I constantly emailed this webpage column boy-servant to all my friends, for the intuitional faculty that if like to peruse it next my friends will too.

  25. Great blog here! Also your site loads up very fast! What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my website loaded up as fast as yours lol

  26. Well I really enjoyed studying it. This post procured by you is very constructive for proper planning.

  27. Marlin Hans says:

    I found your weblog site on google and verify just a few of your early posts. Proceed to maintain up the excellent operate. I simply additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. In search of forward to studying extra from you in a while!…

  28. This web site can be a stroll-by way of for the entire info you wanted about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and you’ll undoubtedly uncover it.

  29. I’m agree with you about Why Eminem Isn’t Elvis | Dan Charnas , but you can write more on this subject.

  30. Right study a several sites to your web site these days, plus i surely such as approach of blogs. I personally saved to fav them if you want to excellent bookmark web page shortlist and will be keeping track of to return rapidly. Could you consider the little web-site at the same time plus move the message how you feel.

  31. Ivan Dinos says:

    DAMN! Congrats for getting your blog on the video in http://earn7700permonth.com mate, keep it up!

  32. msnaddress says:

    …Links…

    [...]It�s laborious to search out educated folks on this subject, however you sound like you already know what you�re speaking about! Thanks[...]…

  33. Similar Blogs…

    This blog also has information that will possibly be of interest to customers…

  34. More Useful Links…

    Other website information…

  35. cash book says:

    …Links…

    [...]you made running a blog glance[...]…

  36. Anonymous says:

    …Websites you should visit…

    [...]I used to be more than happy to search out this internet-site.I wished to thanks in your time for this glorious learn!! I positively having fun with each little little bit of it and I’ve you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you weblog post….

  37. Anonymous says:

    …Websites you should visit…

    [...]Just wanna comment on few general things, The website design is perfect, the content is very good : D.[...]…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Get Updates via Email

Latest Tweets

Why I Wrote “The Big Payback”



To view the entire Big Payback video series, click here

Visit The Archives

Danifestos

The best of the blog, since 2005.

Minding My Own Business, Part One
Minding My Own Business, Part Two
Minding My Own Business, Part Three

My debut posts, rethinking what it means to write about hip-hop.

Blacks and Jews, Part One
Blacks and Jews, Part Two

An untouchable subject, touched.

White People, Get Over Yourselves
A video reaction to candidate Obama's "race speech"

America's Two Destinies
A marination on the legacy of 9-11

zithromax cheap overnight fedex discount Buspar order Alli overnight order Lisinopril usa buy Lisinopril buy Metformin c o d online Metformin order how to get a prednisone rx buying Maxalt online without prescription Maxalt for sale Maxalt no script buy Maxalt united states buy metformin without a rx overnight delivery buy cheap Premarin line buy next day Metformin Metformin canada generic Buspar online buy Maxalt online no prescription ordering Metformin online metformin without rx Metformin uk sales buy Finpecia uk buy Finpecia in the us buy prednisone no rx buy Cytotec cash on delivery buy finpecia without rx needed buy finpecia pills in toronto