Friday, April 28, 2006

Jane



It was late Tuesday night when I heard that Jane Jacobs died. But I was in the middle of editing my documentary, too zoned out from lack of sleep and stress to pause, or process.

Jane Jacobs, I had always told anyone who didn’t know of her, was the woman who saved New York. And, by extension, all American cities.

In the 1950s she was living with her architect husband on Hudson Street in Greenwich Village. On a tip from her spouse, she got a secretarial job at a magazine, Architectural Forum. “By the way,” they said, “you’re also our hospitals and schools editor.”

Thus began, quite by accident, her writing career and her introduction to modern “Urban Renewal.” Unencumbered by training or indoctrination or loyalty, Jacobs quickly discerned that the explosion of urban building — expressways, housing projects, civic centers, and other well-intentioned public works — were instead destroying cities, annihilating the elegant balance of elements that actually made cities work.

This insight got full expression in her 1961 book, “The Death and Life of Great American Cities,” which, from out of nowhere (and from a nobody), completely rocked the urban planning establishment. In simple and sometimes sarcastic language, she simply destroyed the prevailing myths and principles that most people took for granted simply because those theories came from “experts.”

Jacobs derided the lofty Corbusian vision of “towers in a park” that became the blueprint for the superblock housing project. Why, she asked, do these theorists think that “grass, grass, grass” is the answer for urban problems? These projects, which looked so impressive on paper, inevitably became places of worse anomie and crime, with those grassy areas deserted, with grand “promenades that went from nowhere to no place and had no promenaders.”

What did Jacobs celebrate? The block. The corner. The mess of cities. The mix of old and new buildings that kept incomes and ethnicities varied. The mix of uses that always kept “eyes on the street,” making it safer everyone, especially children. She even acknowledged the need for great public works and industry uses that didn’t necessarily lend themselves to street life.

It’s this point that gets ignored by a lot of writers and theorists who have turned on Jacobs, like Nicholai Ouroussoff in the New York Times, unfairly making her name synonymous with the contemporary fetishing of the “neighborhood”: the quaint, antiseptic Gap and Gymboree gentrification that stifles the lifeblood of cities in different ways.

But unlike most armchair experts, Jacobs walked her talk. She was active in protesting the demolition of New York’s Pennsylvania Station — which led to the forming of the city’s first landmarks preservation process. Most famously, she foiled New York’s master builder Robert Moses in his plan to eviscerate of Washington Square Park, and to drive the Lower Manhattan Expressway through Soho and Chinatown, which would have destroyed the Cast Iron District. It did not, because of her.

I thought of Jane Jacobs a lot in the years leading up to my eventual return to New York, for it was she who articulated best the reasons why I could no longer stand to be in a place like Los Angeles. She became, in a sense, an unseen but powerful mentor for me.

Luckily, I had a chance to meet my mentor before she passed, when she gave a talk in San Francisco in May of 2004. At 87, she was on a book tour, believe it or not, for her last tome, “Dark Time Ahead.” She was this frail, hunched-over remnant of a woman, but when she spoke, her voice shook the room. “Anecdotal evidence,” she said, “is really underrated,” defending human reason against the tyranny of research and analysis. When she padded onto the stage in a walker, she got a standing ovation. And when she held an insanely huge megaphone to her ear so she could hear questions from the audience, she got a huge laugh. Afterward, when I got her to sign my copy of “Death and Life,” I told her that I had recently moved back to New York. “Good for you,” she shouted.

That autographed book now sits on the shelf in my apartment as I go about my busy New York life,. A life too busy, I thought, to mourn or reflect on her passing, or even write of it in a blog with a title inspired by her. How ironic.

Until I remembered that I now worked on Hudson Street.

It hadn’t even occurred to me. So yesterday, on a lunch break that I don’t usually take, I stepped into the sunshine and walked from 304 Hudson, past new office buildings and old factories repurposed into gyms and storage warehouses, and into the Village, watching the buildings become smaller, older. Watching children suddenly appear. Shopkeepers sweeping the sidewalk. Bustling cafes with lunchtime traffic.

I walked north until I came to 555 Hudson Street. It was from this building that Jane Jacobs watched her block and, in so doing, discovered how cities work.

I bought some flowers and left them with a small group of offerings that others had left in the wooden doorway, one of which read: “Jane Jacobs, 1916-2006. From this house, a housewife changed the world.” I left my own words, scrawled on a business card bearing my first New York address in 15 years:

“Jane—Thanks for bringing me home.”

After that, it was easier to fight my primal urge to rush back to work. So I stopped at the White Horse Tavern at the end of the block, had a burger and a beer to salute old Mrs. Jacobs, and watched life walk by.

posted by Dan Charnas at 12:03 PM

3 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Good topic, Dan, but a journalism student shouldn't use "simple" and "simply" in the same sentence.

May 08, 2006  
Anonymous The Other Dan Charnas said...

Very nicely written, Dan. You've inspired me to read her books! And the flowers were a very nice gesture.
DC

May 10, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

send your e-mail address to twombombadil@gmail.com

John

wrote to the address provided on your page but it bounced

February 06, 2007  

Post a Comment

<< Home

You're visiting the blog of

DAN CHARNAS

HOLLER AT YOUR BOY
VIEW BIO

Subscribe

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

      Twitter Updates

        follow me on Twitter

            MARINATION

            "It’s not what you’re called, it’s what you answer to."

            --John "Studd" Barrier

              DAN'S QUICK YOGA REMEDIES

              DANIFESTOS

              • Minding My Business - Parts 1, 2 & 3
                on blaming The Man for mess of hip-hop
              • Blacks and Jews - Parts 1 & 2
                on blaming Jews for everything else

              Previous Posts

              • What I Did On My Winter Vacation
              • I Smelled It Too.
              • Happy New Year, Part Two
              • "Blowing Up The Spot With Mics, Not Their Bodies"
              • Happy New Year?
              • You Always Hurt The Ones You Love
              • Elvis Has Left The Building
              • The Bridge to Gretna
              • Slum Clearance, The Natural Way
              • Hooray for Kanye

              Archives

              • April 2005
              • May 2005
              • June 2005
              • July 2005
              • August 2005
              • September 2005
              • October 2005
              • January 2006
              • April 2006
              • May 2006
              • October 2006
              • November 2006
              • December 2006
              • May 2007
              • June 2007
              • August 2007
              • September 2007
              • October 2007
              • January 2008
              • February 2008
              • March 2008
              • June 2008
              • September 2008
              • October 2008
              • November 2008
              • April 2009
              • May 2009
              • April 2010

              Powered by Blogger

              Blog Network:
              Name:
              Dantrification
              Topics:
              hiphop, politics, race
              Join my network
              Blog Networks

               



              Atom Feed